So when I bought my 07 spyder I had a similar issue- nothing on Carfax but the passenger side headlight had a cracked support tab, the washer nozzle on that side had a snapped head, and the hood may have been re-sprayed (Hood doesn't look like it but for some unknown reason the Expel film was removed from the hood only but left on the front bumper, headlights, and fenders)? For me to be certain I removed the entire headlight assembly and frunk liners to see if there was anything structural - everything passed visual inspection and nearest I can assume is that a taller vehicle may have backed into it and hit the headlight only-not even enough to crack the glass? In any case the lack of anything structural and no sign of any re-painting (everything under the liners was appropriately aged and the correct color) sealed the deal for me. I fixed the headlight tab and replaced the headlight washer. I would not walk away-but you do need to inspect the front clip on that vehicle very thoroughly to be certain.